The Clue “I Think I Like When It ___” 2017 song by alt-rock band WILLIS
The Answer RAINS
The answer "RAINS" fits the clue because it is the title of a song by the alt-rock band WILLIS. The song was released in 2017 and includes the line "I Think I Like When It Rains." This phrase captures the mood and theme of the song, making it a perfect match for the crossword clue.